Java fluent builder and inheritance

Question

再过一天，再纠结泛型。

我有一组具有以下继承树的Control对象：

BaseControl
|_SimpleControl
  |_MultipleControl
    |_AutocompleteControl
    |_SelectControl

对于此树中的每个非抽象对象，我想提供构建器，以便可以轻松创建这些对象。这是我到目前为止所拥有的：

BaseControlBuilder：

public abstract class BaseControlBuilder<C extends BaseControl, B extends BaseControlBuilder<C, B>> {
    protected C control;
    private B builder;
    BaseControlBuilder() {
        control = createObj();
        builder = getThis();
    }
    public C build() { return control; }
    protected abstract C createObj();
    protected abstract B getThis();
}

SimpleControlBuilder：

public class SimpleControlBuilder<C extends SimpleControl, B extends SimpleControlBuilder<C, B>>
        extends BaseControlBuilder<SimpleControl, SimpleControlBuilder<C, B>> {
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType controlType) {
        super();
        control.setId(id);
        control.setCaption(caption);
        control.setType(controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final InputType controlType) {
        this("", "", controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType controlType) {
        this(en.name(), en.toString(), controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder<C, B> disabled() {
        control.setDisabled(true);
        return this;
    }
    @Override
    protected SimpleControl createObj() {
        return new SimpleControl();
    }
    @Override
    protected SimpleControlBuilder<C, B> getThis() {
        return this;
    }
}

MultipleControlBuilder：

abstract class MultipleControlBuilder<C extends MultipleControl, B extends MultipleControlBuilder<C, B>>
        extends SimpleControlBuilder<MultipleControl, MultipleControlBuilder<C, B>> {
    MultipleControlBuilder(final InputType type) {
        super(type);
    }
    MultipleControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType type) {
        super(id, caption, type);
    }
    MultipleControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType type) {
        super(en, type);
    }
    public MultipleControlBuilder<C, B> multiple() {
        ((MultipleControl) control).setMultiple(true);
        return this;
    }
}

AutocompleteControlBuilder：

public class AutocompleteControlBuilder<C extends AutocompleteControl, B extends AutocompleteControlBuilder<C, B>>
    extends MultipleControlBuilder<AutocompleteControl, AutocompleteControlBuilder<C, B>> {
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        this("", "", url, autocompleteType);
    }
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final String id,
            final String caption, final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        super(id, caption, InputType.AUTOCOMPLETE);
        ((AutocompleteControl) control).setAutocompleteUrl(url);
        ((AutocompleteControl) control).setAutocompleteType(autocompleteType);
    }
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        this(en.name(), en.toString(), url, autocompleteType);
    }
    @Override
    protected AutocompleteControl createObj() {
        return new AutocompleteControl();
    }
    @Override
    protected AutocompleteControlBuilder<C, B> getThis() {
        return this;
    }
}

但令人惊讶的是，我得到了一些意想不到的结果。
例如，在下面的代码中，我必须将control转换为MultipleControl调用setter，尽管事实上C extends MultipleControl...

此外，以下build()方法调用：new AutocompleteControlBuilder<AutocompleteControl, AutocompleteControlBuilder>("url", AutocompleteType.STANDARD).build());返回SimpleControl而不是没有意义的AutocompleteControl，因为我显式提供了类型参数。

最后一根稻草是，我试图实现的简洁和清晰的代码被丑陋的new AutocompleteControlBuilder<AutocompleteControl, AutocompleteControlBuilder>构造函数调用所扼杀。谁能指出我解决这个问题的最佳实践？

Answer 1

好的，为了正确设置，您应该进行一些更改：

public class SimpleControlBuilder<C extends SimpleControl, B extends SimpleControlBuilder<C, B>>
        extends BaseControlBuilder<SimpleControl, SimpleControlBuilder<C, B>> { // this should extend with the extension classes
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType controlType) {
        super();
        control.setId(id);
        control.setCaption(caption);
        control.setType(controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final InputType controlType) {
        this("", "", controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType controlType) {
        this(en.name(), en.toString(), controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder<C, B> disabled() { // this should return B
        control.setDisabled(true);
        return this;
    }
    @Override
    protected SimpleControl createObj() { // this should return C
        return new SimpleControl();
    }
    @Override
    protected SimpleControlBuilder<C, B> getThis() { // this should return B
        return this;
    }
}

所以这意味着

public abstract class SimpleControlBuilder<C extends SimpleControl, B extends SimpleControlBuilder<C, B>>
        extends BaseControlBuilder<C, B> {
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType controlType) {
        super();
        control.setId(id);
        control.setCaption(caption);
        control.setType(controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final InputType controlType) {
        this("", "", controlType);
    }
    public SimpleControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType controlType) {
        this(en.name(), en.toString(), controlType);
    }
    public B disabled() {
        control.setDisabled(true);
        return getThis();
    }
}

和

abstract class MultipleControlBuilder<C extends MultipleControl, B extends MultipleControlBuilder<C, B>>
        extends SimpleControlBuilder<C, B> {
    MultipleControlBuilder(final InputType type) {
        super(type);
    }
    MultipleControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType type) {
        super(id, caption, type);
    }
    MultipleControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType type) {
        super(en, type);
    }
    public B multiple() {
        control.setMultiple(true);
        return getThis();
    }
}

和

public abstract class AutocompleteControlBuilder<C extends AutocompleteControl, B extends AutocompleteControlBuilder<C, B>>
    extends MultipleControlBuilder<C, B>> {
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        this("", "", url, autocompleteType);
    }
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final String id,
            final String caption, final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        super(id, caption, InputType.AUTOCOMPLETE);
        control.setAutocompleteUrl(url);
        control.setAutocompleteType(autocompleteType);
    }
    public AutocompleteControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final String url,
            final AutocompleteType autocompleteType) {
        this(en.name(), en.toString(), url, autocompleteType);
    }
}

这在 MultipleControl extends SimpleControl 和 AutocompleteControl extends MultipleControl 的情况下有效，并且您有SimpleControl的具体扩展，这些扩展可以使用具有具体化参数的getThis()返回自身。

public class SomeControlBuilder extends MultipleControlBuilder<SomeControl, SomeControlBuilder> {
    public SomeControlBuilder(final InputType type) {
        super(type);
    }
    public SomeControlBuilder(final String id, final String caption,
            final InputType type) {
        super(id, caption, type);
    }
    public SomeControlBuilder(final Enum<?> en, final InputType type) {
        super(en, type);
    }
    @Override
    protected SomeControlBuilder getThis() {
        return this;
    }
    @Override
    protected SomeControl createObj() {
        return new SomeControl();
    }
}