存储过程顺序的结果与在查询分析器中运行时的结果不同



我有一个存储过程,它在调用时返回以下值:

EXEC    @return_value = [dbo].[Activities_GetCrazyTables]
        @iActivity = 49,
        @iLanding = 6,
        @iFirst = 1,
        @iLast = 10,
        @strSearch = '',
        @bActiveOnly = 0

orderkey yellowpage_rownum yellowpage_id yellowpage_name
table4 ,,,,, 1,,,,,, 2022,,,,,, <牛山/kbd>
table4 ,,,,, 2,,,,,, 2055,,,,,, 门多西诺湖
table4 ,,,,, 3,,,,,, 2099,,,,,, 吊灯

但是当我在查询分析器中执行存储过程的实际代码时,它返回的结果不同:

orderkey yellowpage_rownum yellowpage_id yellowpage_name
table4 ,,,,, 1,,,,,, 2022,,,,,, 吊灯
table4 ,,,,, 2,,,,,, 2055,,,,,, 牛山
table4 ,,,,, 3,,,,,, 2099,,,,,, 门多西诺湖

与执行存储过程相比,为什么单独运行查询时会得到正确的排序顺序?

存储过程代码如下:

set @strSearch = LOWER(@strSearch)
select orderkey, y.* from 
(
    /* get the featured sponsors in order specified in the database */
    select ROW_NUMBER() over (order by x.orderkey) as yellowpage_rownum, x.* 
    from (
    /* top tier featured 1-5 */
    select yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, story_count,
    'table1' as orderkey, yellowpage_active from
    (select top 5 a.* from 
    (select ROW_NUMBER() over (order by yellowpage_name) as rownum, yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, (select COUNT(storyyellowpage_story) from storyyellowpagexref join stories on (story_id=storyyellowpage_story) where story_active=1 and storyyellowpage_yellowpage=y.yellowpage_id) as story_count, yellowpage_active
    from yellowpageactivityxref 
    join activities on (activity_id=yellowpageactivity_activity) 
    join yellowpages y on (yellowpage_id=yellowpageactivity_yellowpage) 
    join landingcities on (landingcity_city=yellowpage_city) 
    where yellowpageactivity_activity=@iActivity and landingcity_landing=@iLanding and yellowpage_featuredsponsor=1 and 
        (LOWER(yellowpage_name) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%' or LOWER(yellowpage_address1) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%')) as a 
    where a.rownum between 1 and 5 order by newid()) as b
    union all
    /* top tier featured 6-10 */
    select yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, story_count,
    'table2' as orderkey, yellowpage_active from
    (select top 5 a.* from 
    (select ROW_NUMBER() over (order by yellowpage_name) as rownum, yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, (select COUNT(storyyellowpage_story) from storyyellowpagexref join stories on (story_id=storyyellowpage_story) where story_active=1 and storyyellowpage_yellowpage=y.yellowpage_id) as story_count, yellowpage_active
    from yellowpageactivityxref 
    join activities on (activity_id=yellowpageactivity_activity) 
    join yellowpages y on (yellowpage_id=yellowpageactivity_yellowpage) 
    join landingcities on (landingcity_city=yellowpage_city) 
    where yellowpageactivity_activity=@iActivity and landingcity_landing=@iLanding and yellowpage_featuredsponsor=1 and 
        (LOWER(yellowpage_name) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%' or LOWER(yellowpage_address1) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%')) as a 
    where a.rownum between 6 and 10 order by newid()) as b
    union all
    /* top tier featured 11-15 */
    select yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, story_count,
    'table3' as orderkey, yellowpage_active from
    (select top 5 a.* from 
    (select ROW_NUMBER() over (order by yellowpage_name) as rownum, yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, (select COUNT(storyyellowpage_story) from storyyellowpagexref join stories on (story_id=storyyellowpage_story) where story_active=1 and storyyellowpage_yellowpage=y.yellowpage_id) as story_count, yellowpage_active
    from yellowpageactivityxref 
    join activities on (activity_id=yellowpageactivity_activity) 
    join yellowpages y on (yellowpage_id=yellowpageactivity_yellowpage) 
    join landingcities on (landingcity_city=yellowpage_city) 
    where yellowpageactivity_activity=@iActivity and landingcity_landing=@iLanding and yellowpage_featuredsponsor=1 and 
        (LOWER(yellowpage_name) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%' or LOWER(yellowpage_address1) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%')) as a 
    where a.rownum between 11 and 15 order by newid()) as b
    union all
    /* get the rest and sort by name */
    select yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, story_count,
    'table4' as orderkey, yellowpage_active from
    (select top 2147483647 a.* from 
    (select yellowpage_id, yellowpage_name, yellowpage_address1, yellowpage_address2, yellowpage_city, yellowpage_state, yellowpage_zip, 
    yellowpage_phone, yellowpage_url, yellowpage_latitude, yellowpage_longitude, yellowpage_featuredsponsor, yellowpage_premium, yellowpage_order, 
    yellowpageactivity_order, (select COUNT(storyyellowpage_story) from storyyellowpagexref join stories on (story_id=storyyellowpage_story) where story_active=1 and storyyellowpage_yellowpage=y.yellowpage_id) as story_count, yellowpage_active
    from yellowpageactivityxref 
    join activities on (activity_id=yellowpageactivity_activity) 
    join yellowpages y on (yellowpage_id=yellowpageactivity_yellowpage) 
    join landingcities on (landingcity_city=yellowpage_city) 
    where yellowpageactivity_activity=@iActivity and landingcity_landing=@iLanding and yellowpage_featuredsponsor=0 and 
        (LOWER(yellowpage_name) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%' or LOWER(yellowpage_address1) LIKE '%' + @strSearch + '%')) as a 
    order by yellowpage_name) as b
    ) as x
    ) as y where y.yellowpage_rownum between @iFirst and @iLast

您的查询(Union的结果)没有使用order by语句。这意味着结果的顺序不是确定的,这意味着它在不同的运行中可能是不同的。

要解决这个问题,您需要在最后一个where语句后面添加一个Order by语句:

as y where y.yellowpage_rownum between @iFirst and @iLast Order by col1, col2

您还应该在最后一个查询中消除order by yellowpage_name语句,因为这将与最终结果集的排序无关。

这是一个非常复杂的查询,因此很难理解到底发生了什么。但是,您在完整的结果集中缺少一个Order By

SQL Server是一个关系型数据库。这是这里的关键概念。除非您明确定义希望的顺序,否则数据库引擎不会保证返回的行顺序。您可以在两个不同的地方使用完全相同的查询,并得到不同顺序的结果。

在关系理论中,集合(A, B, C)与(C, B, A)相同,序不相关。

你按orderkey排序,它不是唯一的。具有相同orderkey的行不一定以相同的顺序出现。

扩展你的order by条款来解决问题

最新更新